That's the title of a magazine article that I came across on vacation. I don't recall the magazine or the author's name, but for some reason it really hit home with me.
A little background...I have always considered myself to be a forgiving person. Especially if the transgression was aimed at me. I have a harder time forgiving people who are cruel or thoughtless to those I love. When you really think about that, its a little backwards. I should be harder on those that are nasty to me and let other people fight their own battles. That seems to be how most people do it, anyway.
That being said, for the past year or so I've found that my ability to forgive certain people and certain transgressions has suffered. I now longer want to give "blanket" pardons for things done against me. I want to forgive only when the person in question has truly shown their remorse and not because its expected of me. And I want to forgive with the faith that the behavior in question is truly in the past.
I've struggled with this because there is this pressure to forgive everybody of everything. However, I'm no longer of that school of thought.
So when this article crossed my hands, I realized that this man was saying exactly what I was feeling. I hope you don't mind, but I've typed the article below.
TO FORGIVE IS GOOD, BUT SOMETIMES I WANT TO STAY MAD - Author unknown (OK..I forgot!)
Some years ago, a barrage of thumping, galloping noises routinely issued from the apartment upstairs as if baby elephants were competing in the 50-yard dash. I went up one day to politely inquire. "No, nobody's making noise here" the husband and wife both insisted. It must be coming from elsewhere in the building." Two children about five years old, each holding soccer balls, stood right beside their parents. "Could the thumping be your kids running around, perhaps playing soccer?", I asked. "Oh no, we never let the kids play in the house."
For months, the pattern continued: the thumping and galloping above, our delicate check-in, the denial. It got so that every time I saw the couple, I glared without a word of greeting. When they moved out of the building, the thumping stopped.
I supose I could have forgiven my neighbors this infraction and spared them the glare. After all, forgiveness is in, a trend spawning best-selling books, foundations and research institutes. The notion has gone well beyond spiritual leaders advising that forgiveness is good for the soul and that hard feelings will turn us bitter and hostile. Now the medical community cites studies showing that forgiveness can prevent heart attacks, lower blood pressure and even ease depression.
I may be outnumbered, but I still believe in the healing power of the grudge. I've deployed grudges with an equal-opportunity sense of fairness - against teachers and classmates, bosses and colleagues, family and friends. I've chosen to stop speaking to certain people permanently and occasionally even spoken ill of them - but more with incredulity than a sense of revenge. I'm neither proud nor ashamed. But I've discovered that nothing feels quite as satisfying as a grudge well nursed.
I had a boss who took a dislike to me from my first day on the job, even though she hired me. There were no complaints about my performance, but I later learned she'd lied to co-workers about me. Without explanation, she laid me off after only ten weeks, just before Thanksgiving. I had a family to support. Was I to forgive her? Should I now? GIve me one good reason. My grudge against her balanced out that injustice, somehow righted the universe. It has kept me warm on many a cold night.
Under the new mandate of blanket absolution, should I forgive the cousin who invited us to dinner only to make an Amway pitch? Or the friend who sent me a public relations client and then harrassed me for months for a 10 percent finder's fee?
I'm not against forgiveness per se; I have forgiven people for rudeness as well as for deep misunderstandings and have done so without holding on to hard feelings. What I deplore is the propaganda about forgiveness. No longer an option, forgiveness is an edict. Forgiving so democratically cheapens the very act.
A long standing grudge suggests that we hold certain standards, that we respect ourselves enough to reject bad behavior. Failure to forgive can be just as righteous, just as honorable as forgiveness itself.
When someone apologizes, however, with sincerity, not calculation, it can make a difference. I had a close friend in high school who ditched me after college and has avoided me for all the decades since. At our 15th high school reunion, I had the chance to ask him why. He said that I had always made him feel inferior, as if he gave offense.
And he had a point: I'd made fun of him - I'd thought good-naturedly - until he withdrew. Face-to-face at our reunion, I apologized. He declined.
I know how it feels to go unforgiven. And guess what? It feels deserved.
What I love most about this article is his honesty at the end. We all want to be forgiven for things we've done to others, but sometimes it just isn't possible and that needs to be OK.
For me, the blanket forgiveness that I've shown certain people over the last few years has been detrimental to me because deep down, I really didn't forgive the person all of the way. I forgave them "enough" to play nice, but the action that I was supposed to have forgiven would still lay there, dormant until another incident occurred.
I can easily forgive little things like phone calls not returned, forgotten birthdays, someone doing some harmless venting about me behind my back, silly little misunderstandings. I don't need apologies for those things because we all do them. We all are insensitive, moody, pissy or clueless at some time or another.
My issues are the things that go to the core of who a person is. Disloyalty, brazen backstabbing, a lack of respect for my feelings, taking someone for granted or taking advantage of another....those are the things that I can no longer turn a blind eye too.
I feel good about it.
SIDEBAR: For those of you reading this, please do not assume its about you. This is a general post about my feelings on a generic subject.
Recent Comments